We're Open Starting Wednesday, November 4
Supporting our community with a special PAGOSA STRONG Menu
We are incredibly grateful for our first responders, volunteers, and community members who are coming together to keep one another safe and informed during this challenging time. Our hearts are with our neighbors, our employees and their families, and everyone affected.
Taste What Others Talk About
Posted on Google
Mike McCarthy2 days agoTrustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Amazing food quality. Steak was perfectly cooked. Presentation was excellent. Someone in the back of house knows the fundamentals and execution is on point. Well done!! Waiter and team was also great and very knowledgeable about the menu. Highly recommend this place.+0Posted on Google
Anna Hall14 days agoWonderful dinner this evening. Service and food are equally fabulous!Posted on Google
jack McChesney14 days agoCool jazz elegant casual. Creative well prepared food. Alyssa is awesome. She is well acquainted with the menu and what goe# with what. Ask her.Posted on Google
haylee Le18 days agoThe food are delicious, waiters and waitresses are very nice and helpful especially Alysha . Must try this restaurant if you have a chance to be up here. Normally most of American restaurant’s food is either salty or plain. But this one is very different. Food is fresh and tasty, melted in your mouth.+3Posted on Google
Nallely Macias21 days agoEverything tasted Devine and service was amazing.Posted on Google
Shawn Wheeler30 days agoAbsolutely incredible. Staff so sweet. Large portions worth the price. Great dirty martini. Fresh fish. Fried food wasn’t greasy. Recommend!!!!+1Posted on Google
Jeff Keck37 days agoPosted on Google
Brian Perkins39 days agoElegant and comfy atmosphere. Drinks were perfectly made, food was absolute perfections. Perfect for every occasion.Posted on Google
Paul K. Johnson39 days agoWonderful spot. My server, Alyssa, could not have been any nicer. So accomodating, and a very friendly personality. The food was great, but honestly a marginal meal with this service would be ok!Posted on Google
Michael Mills43 days agoBoth the pork belly and the prime filet were exquisite. Rich, robust flavors! Wonderful service and nice ambiance.
Posted on Tripadvisor
travel96340 days agoVerified
Excellent Very tasty, fresh, delicious. Friendly and cozy atmoshere. I speculate that everything on the menu is good.Posted on Tripadvisor
kirstine201372 days agoOne of the best meals in ages! This was one of best meals I've had in a long time; the food was fresh, tasty & uncluttered by too many sauces. I enjoyed the Thai salad, salmon & shrimp & and an excellent pannacotta. The service was excellent & friendly.Posted on Tripadvisor
Candy H100 days agoGreat food Great food, nice atmosphere. Our waitress was very efficient and did a great job.Posted on Tripadvisor
Joyce W172 days agoPerfect Night! My husband and I dined at Alley House for our 40th anniversary - and had the BEST meals! We had the short rib and baseball cut filet which were cooked to perfection - melted in our mouths. The sides,; house salad and mashed potatoes were delicious also . Our server, Greg treated us like royalty - professional and kind and Jeffers, the manager, was very attentive to us - treating us to a lovely dessert. Fantastic experience , we will definitely make Alley House a destination next time we are in town.Posted on Tripadvisor
Mary K235 days agoVery nice! Not only do they have delicious food (try the calamari) but they’re good, honest people also! My family dined there on Tuesday night after a long day of skiing. It wasn’t until 24 hours later I realized my wallet was missing. (I had kept some cash in my ski pants so I never had needed it). We got back to the house Wednesday evening after skiing and I couldn’t find it. Thought back to the last time I saw it and realized it was, hopefully, there. Vacationer, so I had a large amount of cash in it so I just hoped and prayed someone honest found it. Sure enough, after I described it in great detail they told me it was locked in the safe. I almost cried when they brought it to me, cash still there! We will definitely eat there again next year not only because it was delicious but because they just good people!Posted on Tripadvisor
firesteed419 days agoLoved it! Will be back again! We had a fabulous experience at the Ally House Grille! Two of us had the Elk Tenderloin which was fabulous! I had he Filet Mignon. The only issue I had was I think they got the temperature confused between what the folks who ordered Elk and the other that ordered the Beef. Still was wonderful. Appetizers and Cocktails were great? Infact, I had the best cocktail I have had in a year! Will definitely returnPosted on Tripadvisor
RightTruRvws466 days agoBest meal and service in ages Since covid, it seems universally that it’s hard to get a meal at any restaurant that has both superior food and service. Alley House delivers both exceptionally. Staff works as a team to deliver seamless service. The short rib, house salad & shrimp, shrimp pasta and sea bass were all excellent. Best short rib dinner ever. Great wine list, including some actual good wines by the glass. This is an expensive restaurant, but most likely the best in Pagosa, totally amazing dining experience.Posted on Tripadvisor
Sandy L565 days agoWe Loved It! I loved the atmosphere walking in as soon as we entered. This restaurant is in an older restored house with tables beautifully arranged with white cloths and lovely lighting. The 4 of us all ordered different things and we all raved about the food. If you didn't like everything on a set menu, you could select your main and customize it with different sides, which is what I did. I especially enjoyed my Chilean Sea Bass with a lemon caper sauce with garlic chive whipped potatoes and asparagus. It may be the best Chilean Sea Bass I have ever had and I order it whenever I find it on a menu. Everything was delicious. There is also another more casual section of the restaurant with bar seating as well as tables for those who want to watch TV and eat simpler food.Posted on Tripadvisor
WWTraveler27713 days agoDinner after great day on the mountain 🗻 🏂⛷️🐺 It's a great steak and seafood restaurant. The service was excellent and efficient. However, if you charge ~$250+ for a bottle of Stags Leap, please pretend everyone is fancy and pour the bottle during dinner. The same bottle at the vineyard cost ~$45+/-. I understand the resultant has to pay a markup as well, and we are paying for the experience more than the wine 🍷, but at some point t, it just becomes principle more than anything. Everything was fantastic; the Chillean sea bass and short rib were well prepared. The fire 🔥 place took the chill off after a great day on the mountain 🗻. I would strongly recommend it and will be back. The piano 🎹 above the fireplace was wicked and unique. Thank you for a great visit to Pagosa Springs!Posted on Tripadvisor
Explore13794977142773 days agoParty of 2 for 6pm dinner reservations This restaurant is a nice place for really good food and excellent service. Party of 2 for a 6:00 dinner reservation. My Fiancé had Chilean Sea Bass, Safron Risotto with Steamed Broccoli and I had the Sea Scallops with Safron Risotto and Grilled Brussel Sprouts. Blackberry Cheesecake for dessert. Everything was prepared well and tasted delicious! We both highly recommend this restaurant when in Pagosa Springs! We will be returning!